Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer penned a much talked about Op-ed in the Washington Post yesterday titled “Un-American Attacks Can’t Derail the Health Care Debate.”
The Speaker and Mr. Hoyer breeze through the obligatory caveat saying they believe ”the dialogue between elected representatives and constituents is at the heart of our democracy,” just before slamming the actions of nationalized health care opponents as “Un-American.” To be clear, the column itself is not as inflammatory as the title, Pelosi and Hoyer voice their opposition to “drowning out” the debate with chants and boos, and call out a few cases of truly disruptive behavior. But, on the whole, opponents to nationalized health care have been calm and civil in expressing their concerns to their elected representatives.
What Pelosi and Hoyer consider “un-American” disruption, is an attempt at the substantive debate they claim to want. While the many congressmen who have been confronted at town hall meetings are the ones “drowning out opposing views.”
A reader of National Review Online’s The Corner blog wrote to Rich Lowry this morning about the Pelosi/Hoyer column:
Loved this line from your An Empire of Liberty, quote:”In January 1817 a chastened lame-duck Fourteenth Congress met to debate the issue of exactly what representation meant, and by and large it determined that the people had every right to instruct their congressmen.”
I think that’s the same exact disconnect that is occurring today. The servants have come to think of themselves as the sovereigns.
The NRO reader is right on target, Congressmen are as much servants of the public today as they were in 1817. When town hall meetings across the country are full of angry constituents opposing a bill, chances are the bill is bad—if it’s not a bad bill, then it is the duty of the elected representative to answer constituents questions and persuade them. If he can’t, he should vote the way his constituents choose, or get fired, he is their employee. That’s popular Democracy. . .Isn’t that what the Democratic Party claims to stand for?
For the last eight years Democrats claimed that President Bush and Republicans were calling them un-American, even-though it never happend. Now the same people are actually calling the opposition un-American.